Your answers go to a licensed agent in our Naples office, who compares carriers for your home and gets back to you with price and coverage side by side.
Quotes for condos and townhomes as well as single-family homes
No obligation to buy a policy
Takes about 3-5 minutes to see your options
5.0 ★
from 78 reviews
Independent brokerage since 2017
Over 4,000 policies placed
Naples office
Licensed in 27 states
When something happens to your home, your next call goes somewhere. With Legacy Insurance, it's answered by a licensed agent or account manager in our Naples office, a real person on the phone, not a phone tree or an automated system.
That's only possible because we're independent. Some agents can only sell one company's rates. We compare your home across multiple carriers, including ones built specifically for Florida, and place you with whichever one fits.
FAQ
WHY A LOCAL BROKER
Price alone doesn’t tell you how a policy holds up when something happens. You usually see a better rate once you compare options across the market, but the real priority is making sure your home is properly covered. Every quote comes with a coverage review alongside the price.
"I was so impressed with how quickly they were able to insure my house. Very easy to work with."
— Janet Elkins
"Excellent insurance company and very pleasant, attentive and professional customer service from the outset. They found us a better policy for less money."
— Manuel Arcos
"Excellent work to significantly reduce my homeowners insurance. Helpful and professional!"
— Dan Miller
OUR LEADERSHIP
Chief Executive Officer
Craig co-founded Legacy Insurance on one principle: insurance should feel personal, not transactional. That standard shapes how every quote gets handled out of our Naples office.
The agents and account managers on the team carry that same approach into every conversation, comparing your home across the market and reviewing your coverage instead of just chasing the lowest price.
Craig co-founded Legacy Insurance on one principle: insurance should feel personal, not transactional. That standard shapes how every quote gets handled out of our Naples office.
The agents and account managers on the team carry that same approach into every conversation, comparing your home across the market and reviewing your coverage instead of just chasing the lowest price.